Skip to content
Gift Cards
Contact Us
My Account/Login
Cart
Everything We Have
Best Sellers
Award Winners
Our Varieties
Gifts
About Us
Widmer’s Legacy
Where to Buy
Then and Now
Story of Brick Cheese
Meet the Master Cheese Maker
Factory Tour
Cheddar Cheese
Our Blog
Search for:
Search for:
Award Winners
Sort by
Default Order
Sort by
Name
Sort by
Price
Sort by
Date
Sort by
Popularity
Sort by
Rating
Show
12 Products
Show
12 Products
Show
24 Products
Show
36 Products
View Cart
Rated
4.83
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
10 Year Aged Cheddar 1 lb
$
22.40
View Cart
Rated
5.00
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
6 Year Aged White Cheddar 1 lb
$
14.20
View Cart
Rated
4.75
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
Colby Whole Loaf 5 lb
$
35.00
View Cart
Rated
5.00
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
Colby Half Loaf 2.5 lb
$
18.00
View Cart
Rated
4.92
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
Colby Loaf 1 lb
$
7.50
View Cart
Rated
5.00
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
Caraway Colby 1 lb
$
7.85
View Cart
Rated
5.00
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
1 Year Aged Cheddar 1 lb
$
7.85
View Cart
Add to cart
/
Details
1 Year Aged Cheddar 2 lb
$
15.40
View Cart
Add to cart
/
Details
1 Year Aged Cheddar 5 lb
$
36.50
View Cart
Rated
5.00
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
2 Year Aged Cheddar 1 lb
$
8.85
View Cart
Rated
5.00
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
4 Year Aged Cheddar 2 lb
$
23.30
View Cart
Rated
5.00
out of 5
Add to cart
/
Details
4 Year Aged Cheddar 5 lb
$
52.00
1
2
3
Next
